You have the dashboard. It shows which prompts cite you, which cite your competitors, and how that moves week to week. The part nobody sells you is what to change on Monday.

One team has an answer. A commenter who goes by u/RankControl says they tagged 308 citations from 24 buying questions, and on software questions, roundups and alternatives pages made up 118 of the 167 citations. Their takeaway was to decide which page type to publish for each question.

I like that as a hypothesis to test. It is a long way from a proven roadmap, and the same thread shows why.

The exchange happened on r/GEO_optimization, in a thread posted November 6, 2026 by a user named ArfadiaOfficial. The question was blunt: once you can see where you are cited, what decision does the data change?

ArfadiaOfficial listed the usual options. Rewrite the cited page, which is risky if the citation is why the page works. Work on pages that are never cited. Build the third-party sources engines like to quote. Or change nothing and treat the data as a report.

u/RankControl replied first, with numbers from their own tagging. On services questions, explainers and the firms' own service pages took about 70 percent of citations. In their words, "what the data gives you is a list of missing page types." They said they have not tested rewriting cited pages and would treat it as risky.

The format engines cite follows what the question is asking. A software shopper asking for options gets roundups and alternatives pages. Someone asking about a service gets explainers and a firm's own service pages. If you have the service page and no explainer, the tagging points at the explainer. If you have neither a roundup nor an alternatives page for a software category, the same tagging points there.

The same comment added a pricing example. Only 7 of the 308 citations were pricing pages, but u/RankControl says Google AI Overviews and Perplexity both repeated Help Scout's $25/$45/$75 without saying the prices were annual, because the toggle defaulted to annual. Their fix is to put the billing period next to every price.

They did not claim a clean before-and-after comparison. In a check of 10 posts that SaaS companies published one to three months earlier, they say Perplexity had picked up 7 as sources, Google AI Overviews 3, and ChatGPT none. That is a snapshot, not a timing study. u/RankControl suggests keeping untouched control pages to compare against, and ArfadiaOfficial agreed that without them, any change on treated pages can't be falsified.

Then u/Ken_Numbers arrived. His first reply was one line: "You cannot see where you are cited." Asked what he meant, he posted eight problems.

The first is that there is no defined population of prompts. Share of voice needs a denominator, he wrote, and vendors measure against a list they or the client invented, "so the metric describes the list, not the market." The same prompt can return different answers and citations across runs. Personalization changes what each user sees. Tools often query a different surface than real users do. And no provider publishes first-party data a tool could be checked against.

Each point is a fair complaint about dashboards sold on a single score. A mention, a citation and a recommendation are three different events, he argued, and most tools fold them into one number. That matters here because a page-type count is a citation count, and it inherits the same blind spots.

ArfadiaOfficial conceded the prompt-population and query-volume points as the load-bearing pair and called the last two unsolved. Their reading was that citation data works as a floor: if competitors are cited and you're absent, that gap is real even without a denominator.

Semrush made a related point on X on November 5, 2026. Its post says that 62 percent of AI citations are "ghost citations", where the site is cited but the brand isn't explicitly mentioned. The post gives no sample or method, and Semrush sells tracking tools.

Where I land

Disclosure: my agency, ViewEngine, sells AI visibility work and builds its own tracking tools.

I think the page-type reading is worth testing, because it asks the data a question it can plausibly answer. A sample of citations shows what engines picked for the prompts you ran. It does not show every page they retrieved, and it does not show that publishing a missing format will earn you anything. Ken_Numbers' objections about sampling and run-to-run variation apply to a gap list as much as to a share-of-voice score.

My guess is that the useful result is a short list of formats to try, with the pages that follow held against untouched controls. The outcomes to watch are recommendations and brand mentions, and a citation pattern is only a hint about where to look.

Free newsletter

The Sherpa Brief

One email a week on what changed in AI search, what it means, and what to do about it. Written for marketers, SEOs, and publishers.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.