You have heard the advice. Get your brand onto the "best of" lists that AI answers read, and the AI starts recommending you. In the GEO agency business, the agencies write those lists about themselves, and Google's AI reads them.

When we pulled the results on November 16, 2026, Google's AI Overview for "best GEO agency" named six agencies. Three of them sit on a ranked list in a YouTube video the answer cited. Rock The Rankings uploaded that video and ranks itself first.

My read: for this query, Google's AI is drawing on the sellers' own rankings, and the sellers doing the ranking show up in the answer.

It started with a joke from Lily Ray on X.

On November 15, Ray, an SEO with a large following, posted a chart of a company's falling organic visibility. "They also call their own company the "best GEO agency in 2027" on their site already, lol ok 🤣" she wrote.

She did not name the company. "I'd love nothing more than to share names publicly and there are many reasons I don't," Ray said in a reply. I won't name it either.

The timing gave the joke an edge. Google's November 2026 core update began rolling out on November 10, according to ALM Corp. Ray followed up with a warning: "When the SEO/GEO "strategy" is basically this, but at scale, don't be surprised that Google is able to detect these patterns without much effort."

One reply argued that Google traffic is not the whole picture for a GEO shop. Ray answered with the company's numbers from Ahrefs: "Oh yeah, 14 AI Overview appearances and 9 pages cited in ChatGPT according to @ahrefs Brand Radar, really crushing GEO." Appearances and cited pages are not leads. Neither side settles much with those numbers.

What Google's AI says when you ask

Ray's post was about one company. A buyer should care more about what Google's AI says when you search for a GEO agency yourself.

AEO Sherpa's topic radar checked on the afternoon of November 15. We pulled Google's live US desktop results for "best GEO agency" through DataForSEO. The AI Overview named seven agencies: Rock The Rankings, First Page Sage, Flying Cat Marketing, Omniscient Digital, Siege Media, iPullRank and Orbit Labs.

One of its six sources was Flying Cat's own roundup, The Best GEO Agencies for B2B SaaS. It lists twelve agencies and puts Flying Cat, "our agency", first.

Flying Cat's page The Best GEO Agencies for B2B SaaS, with its opening line naming Flying Cat first among twelve agencies
Flying Cat's roundup opens by naming itself first, and Google's AI Overview cited it on November 15. Screenshot: Flying Cat, Nov. 16, 2026

Its founder, Maeva Cifuentes, writes on the page that she competes with every agency on the list.

The next morning, a different answer

We ran the same pull on November 16 at about 6:27 AM ET, with the same location, device and tool. Flying Cat's list was gone from the sources, and Flying Cat was gone from the answer. The named agencies were now Searchbloom, Rock The Rankings, First Page Sage, Intero Digital, Botpresso and Breaking B2B. Only Rock The Rankings and First Page Sage appeared both days.

The answer cited seven sources: a GoodFirms directory page, Omnius's GEO service page, an r/SaaS thread, a post in r/obility and three YouTube videos.

One of those videos is The 14 Best B2B SaaS GEO & AI Search Agencies for 2027. Rock The Rankings uploaded it on November 1. It ranks Rock The Rankings first with a score of 9.6 out of 10, First Page Sage second and Breaking B2B sixth. All three were in Google's answer that morning.

The r/obility post, Top Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) Agencies for B2B Marketing, sits in Obility's own subreddit. It ranks Obility first and describes it in the first person: "Our teams monitor client and competitor presence in AI search results." Google cited the post but did not name Obility, and it did not name Omnius either.

Orbit Labs went the other way. It was in the November 15 answer and missing on November 16, when the answer cited an r/SaaS thread where a commenter opened with "Founder of Orbit Labs here" and suggested adding it to a buyer's shortlist.

Buyers in these threads have noticed. "What I'd use to build your own shortlist, since most of the lists floating around were written by people on them," one commenter, u/Swetha_official, wrote under the Obility post.

Who writes the answer

Of the seven sources on November 16, I can confirm three were written by an agency promoting itself: the Obility post, the Omnius page and the Rock The Rankings video. I am not counting the other two videos, because I could not confirm who made them.

This fits something I have believed for a while. What counts is everything the AI can find about your brand, and what it concludes after reading it. For this query, a large share of what Google's AI can find was written by the sellers. A self-ranked list is cheap to publish, and for at least one agency it lined up with a spot in the answer on both days we checked.

Ray's chart points the other way for the blue links. Authority has to come before content at scale, and Google's ranking systems tend to catch sites that skip that step. Whether the AI layer ever discounts a self-ranked list, two pulls can't tell us.

The overnight change is the other lesson. Two answers a day apart differed, and two observations can't say why. AI visibility is probabilistic, and one answer is noise. If an agency shows you a single screenshot of itself in an AI Overview, ask for the prompt set it tracks and how often each prompt runs.

Disclosure: my agency, ViewEngine, sells AI visibility work and builds its own tracking tools.

I don't expect agencies to stop ranking themselves. I would just like buyers to know who wrote the list before they book the call.

Free newsletter

The Sherpa Brief

One email a week on what changed in AI search, what it means, and what to do about it. Written for marketers, SEOs, and publishers.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.