If you're about to rewrite your URLs to win AI citations, don't lean on Google's newest video. It says the words in a URL barely move rankings, and rankings are a different question.
Google Search's Gary Illyes called keywords in a URL "an incredibly small signal" that become "basically irrelevant" once a page has content. He said it in the premiere of a new video series that Google describes as useful for generative AI features too. The episode never mentions AI answers.
My read is that URL words are a weak lever for citations as well. That is a read, and the rest of this piece shows where it stops.
The series is The Non-Canonical Cabinet, and Google posted the first episode on October 14, 2026. Illyes and his co-host, Cherry Prommawin, work through the edge cases of URLs. Asked whether stuffing a URL with keywords makes a page number one forever, Illyes answered, "No, not even a little. I mean, it is an incredibly small signal." He added, "It really only matters when we have absolutely nothing else to go on."
His example was a site that is two seconds old with no content. Once Google sees content on the page, he said, the keywords in the domain and the URL become basically irrelevant. The episode also recommends hyphens as the word separator in a URL path and says simple, readable URLs are better for users. Search Engine Roundtable adds that Illyes made a point of saying Google can detect spamming in URLs, which is a fair warning to anyone tempted to pile keywords into a path.
Search Engine Roundtable covered the video as a ranking story and linked a long run of earlier Google statements that say much the same. Google's own description of the series says its questions are "still useful for Search and generative AI features," but the episode explains nothing about how an answer engine reads a URL.
The AI question showed up the same day
An r/TechSEO poster, u/HumanBehavi0ur, argued that URL structure shapes AI citations. Their claim is that AI crawlers build a topic map of a site and that the URL path is one of the easiest signals to read. The thread is small, with four replies and no upvotes. I take it as the question people are asking, not as evidence.
The replies split. u/BoGrumpus said the information structure matters more than the URL strings, and that a URL is only one way to show it. u/sabrinaoahu reported ugly product URLs that still get cited when the page answers the question, and clean category paths that ChatGPT ignores.
The most useful reply was about method. u/marintkael wrote that AI answers change between runs. A before-and-after URL test needs the same questions asked several times each, they wrote, and without repeats the difference is mostly noise.
What a real answer would look like
I agree with that method point. AI visibility is probabilistic, and one answer before a URL change plus one after tells you almost nothing. A real test would collect the URLs that several engines cite for the same queries, sort them into descriptive paths and ID-style paths, and compare that mix with the organic top 10, across many runs.
Even then it would show correlation. Pages with descriptive paths may also be better pages, on stronger sites, with cleaner internal links, and an engine can read a page without citing it. Google's ranking statement can't fill that gap, because the video describes how Google handles URLs and not how ChatGPT or Perplexity pick sources.
My guess is that page content decides the citation and a readable path mostly helps people recognize a link. It is only a guess. What I can say is that I haven't seen a study showing URL wording changes what gets cited, and Search Engine Roundtable's list includes Google telling people not to change URLs just for SEO. Until a test exists, I'd leave working URLs alone.
Free newsletter
The Sherpa Brief
One email a week on what changed in AI search, what it means, and what to do about it. Written for marketers, SEOs, and publishers.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click.



