You open Search Console's new AI report, see a chart of impressions and no clicks, and start to wonder if nobody clicks. Dan Petrovic, founder of DEJAN, asked that out loud on November 9, 2026, and a reply to him went further and said Google is hiding a number of zero.

One site's experiment says otherwise. Cyrus Shepard, founder of Zyppy, estimated a click-through rate of about 0.9 percent for links in Google's AI features on his own site. The site's rate across all of Google Search is about 0.4 percent.

That is one site, and it proves nothing about yours. It does show that a metric Google leaves out is not a metric that equals zero.

Shepard ran the experiment first. He excluded Zyppy from Google's AI features on September 1, 2026 and opted back in on September 29. Before the exclusion the site had 500 to 1,000 AI impressions a day, about 10 percent of its search impressions. After it, none.

He compared total clicks across the two 28-day periods and matched queries and positions to limit the noise. Shepard wrote in his newsletter, "This analysis estimated an AI search CTR of ~0.9%, with a reasonable range of 0.7%-1.1%." Those clicks are an estimate. Google does not report them.

The rate matters because of the mix. AI features made up about a tenth of the site's search impressions but clicked at roughly double the site's usual rate. On that arithmetic Shepard put their share of the site's search clicks at about 21 percent. He is blunt about the limits. His post calls it a single experiment on a single site and a "directional yardstick," and says AI visibility varies wildly across publishers.

Search Engine Journal's Matt G. Southern explains why Shepard had to work that way. Google counts a click on an AI Overview or AI Mode link as a standard click in the Performance report, with no filter to separate it. The clicks sit inside your total.

Petrovic posted his screenshot of the report at 03:14 UTC on November 9. His caption read, "Why not show clicks here? Maybe there's none to show." Google's help page says the report covers AI Overviews and AI Mode and that its chart displays total impressions. It offers pages, countries, dates and devices, and no clicks. Google also says that values shown as a dash in the report become zeros in the exported data, which is one more reason not to read a blank as a measurement.

A reply from Mike Blazer, an SEO who posts on X as @MikeBlazerX, took the missing column as proof. He wrote that Google "is uncomfortable with the fact that AI overviews don't send any clicks." It is a low-reach reply, and the evidence cuts against it. Shepard's estimate does not give a web-wide rate, but it does contradict the claim that AI links send no clicks.

What may change on December 3

The UK may force the question for UK traffic. Southern reports that the Competition and Markets Authority gives Google until December 3 to provide publishers with impressions, clicks and click-through rate for AI search features. The metrics are aggregated across features such as AI Overviews and AI Mode, and the rules cover results shown to people in the UK.

Southern puts the gap plainly: "Clicks and click-through rate for AI features are the numbers Shepard had to estimate." Nothing I have read says those numbers will reach every property worldwide.

Until they arrive, and for any site outside the UK, I would read the report as an exposure report. It tells you how often Google shows your pages in AI answers. It tells you nothing about what readers do next.

I would export the AI impressions by page now. If click data does arrive, a baseline from before it will be worth having. Either way, an absent metric cannot answer the traffic question, and I would not let anyone's reading of a blank column answer it for you.

Free newsletter

The Sherpa Brief

One email a week on what changed in AI search, what it means, and what to do about it. Written for marketers, SEOs, and publishers.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.