You've probably been told that ChatGPT and Perplexity cite mostly different sites than Google, and that each engine needs its own plan. Then ask how much one engine agrees with itself.

Babel42, a firm that sells AI visibility software, says Google's AI Overviews cited an identical set of sites as the day before in only 11.3 percent of its daily comparisons. If one engine disagrees with itself that often, a low overlap between two engines tells you much less than the chart implies.

My read: a cross-engine overlap number is not usable until someone reports the same engine's overlap with itself, measured the same way.

The question came from Lily Ray on October 20, 2026. The SEO consultant wrote on X: "I’ve never understood how studies that look at citation overlap across LLMs account for the fact that citations can also be different within each LLM for the same prompt every time the response is generated."

A reply from @brendenvonhouse, a small account, put the logic plainly: "the same prompt can cite a different set of sources on the next run, so one answer per model is a single sample. overlap between two models means little until you know how much each one overlaps with itself."

The self-overlap number that exists

Babel42 published the closest thing to that baseline I can find, on October 12, 2026. It ran 660 commercial Google searches in the US across six industries on September 26, then reran 601 of them every day at 13:00 UTC from September 28 to October 12. This is a daily comparison over two weeks, not repeated runs of one prompt in a single sitting.

The first-listed source changed in 42.3 percent of searches from one day to the next, Babel42 reports. It also reports that none of the 418 searches with an AI Overview on all 15 days cited the same set of sites every day.

The same study compared two Google surfaces. For 475 searches where both answered on the same day, AI Overviews and AI Mode had on average 32.5 percent of their cited sites in common, and in 10.1 percent of searches they shared no site at all.

Those two numbers do not subtract. The 11.3 percent counts a day as a match only when the whole set of cited sites is identical. The 32.5 percent is an average share of sites in common. They are different measures, which leaves me unable to say whether AI Overviews and AI Mode are far apart or about as close as AI Overviews is to itself.

Babel42 says its data covers high-volume US commercial searches, not everything people search.

Why the other numbers worry me

On r/aeo the same day, a commenter who says they build Hasmord, an AEO sales platform, wrote that only 8 to 13 percent of the sites cited by ChatGPT and Perplexity overlapped Google's. By the commenter's account, that came from 60 shopping questions on one day. No self-overlap number came with it.

Stability may also differ by engine. A practitioner posting as @danielmartin_a said his April runs on CRM pricing prompts showed 40 percent source-mix overlap in ChatGPT against 95 percent in Perplexity, across three repeat runs each. That is self-reported, with no prompt list. If it holds up, one baseline for all engines would not work either.

Disclosure: my agency, ViewEngine, sells AI visibility work and builds its own tracking tools.

My own habit follows from how I think about measurement. A single answer is noise. I want many runs of many prompts, and I would report each engine's overlap with itself next to its overlap with the others, using one metric. Ten to twenty runs per prompt is my rule of thumb, not an established threshold. Even then, the comparison shows how far apart two engines sit against how much each moves alone. It does not isolate a clean engine effect. Until an overlap chart comes with that baseline, I would not move budget because of it.

Free newsletter

The Sherpa Brief

One email a week on what changed in AI search, what it means, and what to do about it. Written for marketers, SEOs, and publishers.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.